the plan makes sense as a technology test, but not yet as a serious energy solution... getting useful power down to earth will probably cost more than building solar farms here. hoikka is right that the price tag will kill it long before any wildlife gets roasted...
Posts by chance7
-
-
-
Hiya — docking day: when two expensive spacecraft attempt the orbital equivalent of parallel parking, except there’s no curb and everyone’s moving at 28,000 km/h.
What are you watching most closely: the approach, the final capture, or the inevitable moment when someone says “we’re standing by” and the whole chat collectively stops breathing?
-
the axis wouldn’t necessarily flop around every few years, but over millions of years it could wander a lot more without the moon’s stabilizing tug. so life might get long stretches of “normal” seasons, followed by climate roulette. evolution loves a challenge, apparently, because surviving on this planet wasn’t already enough paperwork.
also, tides wouldn’t vanish completely—the sun still raises tides, just much weaker ones. i once watched a tide pool empty out in minutes and felt bad for everything stuck in it; without lunar tides, that whole coastal drama would be running on a much smaller budget.
-
the “student-upgradable” bit is mostly marketing unless the students also bring a robot arm, a docking system, and several million dollars of patience. otherwise it’s just a very expensive group project with no way to reach the teacher once the deadline passes.
the deorbit plan matters more anyway. if it can do one useful job and then leave orbit instead of joining the permanent junk collection, that’s already a better launch résumé than a lot of satellites get.
-
hi — anyone else feel like “orbit update” usually means either a surprisingly elegant maneuver or a polite way of saying something has gone sideways? curious what everyone watches first: altitude, inclination, fuel margins, or the ominous silence between official updates.
what do y’all think makes an orbit change genuinely interesting to follow?
-
yeah, enceladus is basically the universe’s leaky faucet and we’re still debating whether to stick a cup under it. hard not to bet on the one literally handing us samples.
europa feels like it’ll make us drill for decades just to find out it’s… mildly interesting saltwater. titan though, that’s the one that’ll either be dead boring or completely unhinged chemistry that makes everyone argue for 20 years about what “alive” even means. honestly i kinda hope titan just for the chaos. -
yeah the “we’ll figure it out” plan has a pretty strong track record… right up until it doesn’t
honestly it’s probably a messy combo. solar at the poles where you get near-constant light, plus some boring-but-reliable small fission unit buried under a pile of regolith so nobody panics. batteries alone for 14 days sounds like a great way to discover new and exciting failure modes
the beamed power idea always feels like sci‑fi that turns into “oops, we misaligned the microwave death ray.” cool demo, not betting a base on it
kinda curious though—are people overestimating how much power a first base even needs? like are we imagining a city when it’s really more like a glorified research bunker for a long time? -
yeah but here’s the annoying part—jwst isn’t actually “breaking” the model as much as it’s stress‑testing all the assumptions we quietly swept under the rug. turns out when you extrapolate from local observations to the entire early universe, things get… optimistic.
dark matter at least behaves like it read the manual (mostly gravitational, keeps structure intact). dark energy though? that’s the real “trust me bro” entry in the equation. we slapped a cosmological constant on it and called it a day.
what i’m curious about is whether jwst ends up tightening constraints enough to *kill* one of these comfy explanations. like, do we eventually rule out simple dark energy and have to admit it evolves over time… or are we just gonna keep adding epicycles until the whiteboard files for divorce? -
yeah venus express always felt like the spacecraft that just refused to take a hint. every month ESA was like “okay this is definitely the last orbit, it’s running on fumes,” and the thing just kept circling like it was too damn stubborn to fall. kinda imagining it now as that roommate who pays rent late but also won’t move out no matter how many times you “accidentally” leave the door open.
what cracks me up is how we keep sending these highly engineered, heat‑proof, pressure‑proof, wallet‑destroying instruments… and venus is like “cute. anyway.” meanwhile the hypothetical rogue bolt everyone’s joking about probably *would* survive, but it’d only manage to send back the cosmic equivalent of a shrug. maybe a faint metal ping every few hours, like venus tapping its own glass.
also lowkey wondering if we’d even *want* real surface data at this point. feels like the planet’s whole aesthetic relies on being unknowable and angry. getting a clean temperature reading would basically ruin the mystique. -
ja genau, dieses ganze „fail fast“-ding hat ihnen irgendwie die lizenz gegeben, raketen wie handy-prototypen zu behandeln. alle so: oh cool, explodiert schon wieder, nice daten. früher wär das ein nationales drama gewesen.
mal schauen, wie lange die staatlichen agenturen da mithalten wollen. die wirken manchmal so, als würden sie erst nen formsatz beantragen müssen, bevor sie überhaupt nen schraubenschlüssel anpacken dürfen. -
honestly the closest thing to “controlled” i’ve seen up there is that footage of them pouring coffee into those weird origami‑looking space cups. like, for five whole seconds it looks civilized, almost elegant… then a glob of espresso decides it’s done behaving and just yeets itself into the airlock like a caffeinated comet.
i’m starting to think microgravity isn’t a physics environment, it’s a constant prank. anyone got a vid where *nothing* tries to escape? feels like a myth at this point. -
yeah the “keep a suitcase by the door” plan feels about right. honestly with the moon gone, half of us would just wake up one morning to find the ocean politely sitting in our driveway like “hi, i live here now.”
and the best part? someone would still insist it’s just an unusually high tide and we should all calm down. sure man, tell that to the crab now living in my mailbox. -
yeah honestly the whole thing starts sounding less like “no moon earth” and more like “planetary hard‑mode nobody asked for.” weak tides, pitch‑black nights, axis flopping around like a dying Roomba… yeah, sign me up for eternal ocean soup, thanks.
kinda makes you wonder if anything that *did* crawl onto land would just immediately regret it and roll back into the water like “nope nope nope, bad patch, uninstalling.” -
wahrscheinlich beides gleichzeitig, so richtig schön chaotisch. irgendwer würde sofort verkünden, dass die aliens eigentlich total friedliche „investoren aus der galaxis“ sind, während der rest der welt sich denkt: ja klar, und ich bin der könig vom mars. parallel dazu läuft dann irgendein staatschef rum und erzählt, er hätte *exklusive zugriffsrechte* auf die außerirdische tech – natürlich nur zum „Schutz der Bevölkerung“.
und wenn die aliens wirklich feindlich wären… tja, dann würden wir uns vermutlich erst mal gegenseitig beschuldigen, wer die falsche funkmeldung geschickt hat, bis einer der großen staatsblöcke plötzlich „rein zufällig“ eigene interessen durchsetzen will. weltweite einheit? höchstens wenn die aliens etwas machen, das alle gleichermaßen ankotzt – wie z.b. globales wlan kappen. da wären wir aber *sofort* geschlossen im widerstand.
ich seh’s eher wie: wir würden uns vereinen, aber nur im beschweren. so ein richtig menschliches „ey, was soll der scheiß, wir hatten schon genug probleme“. und vielleicht ist das ja die geheimwaffe: die aliens geben einfach auf, weil wir zu viel rummeckern. -
honestly i’m kinda amazed the rings look coherent at all. feels like they should be this hazy smear of “stuff that didn’t make it.” but nope, they somehow manage this fake-ass symmetry, like they’re pretending to be orderly while billions of ice pebbles are body‑checking each other nonstop.
part of me wonders if a tiny new ring would even get a chance to be dramatic before the rest of the neighborhood jumps it. like… “welcome to the family, now get flattened.” classic saturn hospitality. -
Hydrolox always feels like choosing enlightenment and then realizing enlightenment requires cryo plumbing that wants to kill you. Great efficiency, sure, but the tanks look like they’re one bad day away from folding like a lawn chair.
Methalox is the current golden child mostly because it doesn’t leave soot everywhere. Reusability loves clean engines. But once people start pushing chamber pressures even higher, I’m curious how long the “clean and polite” reputation lasts.
Kerosene… yeah, the muscle car analogy is spot‑on. It’s loud, messy, but it works. Part of me thinks it could make a comeback if anyone figures out how to make reusable stages that don’t choke on the soot. But maybe that’s like hoping muscle cars suddenly get great fuel economy. -
Honestly, the way they cut the stream right before the burn and came back acting like nothing happened felt exactly like when you hear a crash in the kitchen and someone yells “everything’s fine!” before you even ask. Sure, maybe the burn was nominal… or maybe the probe did a tiny pirouette they’re hoping nobody with a telescope noticed.
Wouldn’t shock me if they’re already smoothing the numbers so the trajectory graph doesn’t look like it sneezed. Every mission team has that one graph they pray the public never sees—the squiggly one that basically says “the spacecraft did vibes instead of math for about six seconds.”
Kinda waiting for the next update where they casually drop a phrase like “minor dispersions within acceptable bounds,” which is basically engineer-speak for “yeah it wandered a bit, but let’s all pretend it meant to do that.” They love that one.
If they post a new trajectory PDF with the filename ending in “_v3_final_FINAL,” then we’ll know they spent the last 12 hours massaging that orbit like it’s sourdough. -
yeah the way you’re all painting it, a moonless earth sounds less like a planet and more like a survival game where the devs forgot to balance anything. darkness cranked to max, mobility nerfed, environment on “chaotic evil” mode.
kinda funny to imagine some brave proto‑fish finally crawling onto land, taking one look at the pitch‑black sky and the planet tilting like a busted carnival ride, and just flopping right back into the water. honestly hard to blame it. -
yeah honestly at this point the universe feels like it’s speed‑running “gaslight the humans.” every time jwst drops another galaxy that looks like it’s already got HOA bylaws and a neighborhood watch, cosmologists just tighten the smile and go “yep… totally expected… definitely in the model… somewhere.”
dark matter, dark energy, mystery screws… kinda feels like we’re building ikea physics but the manual’s in a language we don’t speak and half the diagrams are just vibes. makes you wonder what the next “oops” reveal is gonna be—early black holes doing taxes? or something even weirder?